Home/Horses/Pony of the Americas/Under $2,500

Pony of the Americas horses for sale priced Under $2,500

107 listings

107 Pony of the Americas horses for sale on other sites Everybarn indexes. Asking prices run from $300 to $2,500, with a median of $1,200 across 107 prices. Based on 107 listings, updated Oct 8, 2026. The most listings are in Deloit, IA (7), Columbia, MO (4) and Hillsdale, MI (4). Typical range nationally $850 to $3,000, from 151 comparable sales and listings in the past 90 days.

Everybarn Verified

Breed 1▼

Quarter Horse5471 Paint2722 Appaloosa746 Thoroughbred1017 Arabian1348 Morgan190 Tennessee Walking Horse23 Missouri Fox Trotter177 Standardbred107 Warmblood173 Friesian72 Draft (Percheron, Belgian, Clydesdale, Shire)318 Miniature Horse59 Mustang226 American Saddlebred4 Rocky Mountain Horse4 Kentucky Mountain Saddle Horse3 Paso Fino154 Peruvian Horse46 Icelandic Horse1 Gypsy Vanner9 Lusitano6 Haflinger109 Norwegian Fjord1 Curly30 National Show Horse2 Trakehner12 Hanoverian11 Shire11 Welsh Pony and Cob184 Shetland Pony112 Connemara8 ✓Pony of the Americas107 Hackney47 Westphalian3 Lipizzan8 Spotted Saddle Horse19 Racking Horse10 Donkey111 Mule217 Show 107 horses

Distance ▼

Show 107 horses

Fair Value ▼

Great price Fair price Above market Show 107 horses

More filters ▼

Age

Sex

Gelding4 Stallion54 Mare49

Height (hands)

Color

Bay14 Chestnut5 Sorrel10 Black5 Palomino1 Buckskin1 Roan3 Other8

Show 107 horses

Pony of the Americas ✕$0 to $2,500 ✕Clear all

Horse

Pony of the Americas

Pony of the Americas · Stallion · 2 yrs

Victory, WI

Source: HorseWeb

Horse

Pony of the Americas

Pony of the Americas · Mare

Newberry, FL

Source: HorseWeb

Horse

Pony of the Americas

Pony of the Americas · Mare · 20 yrs

Russellville, AL

Source: HorseWeb

Poa (Pony of the Americas, Gelding) in Prundale, CA

Poa

Pony of the Americas · Gelding · 15 yrs

Prundale, CA

Source: HorseWeb

Pony of the Americas (Pony of the Americas, Mare) in Arlington, MN

Pony of the Americas

Pony of the Americas · Mare · 27 yrs

Arlington, MN

Source: HorseWeb

Poa (Pony of the Americas, Gelding) in Franktown, CO

Poa

Pony of the Americas · Gelding · 10 yrs

Franktown, CO

Source: HorseWeb

Pony of the Americas (Pony of the Americas, Mare) in Casper, WY

Pony of the Americas

Pony of the Americas · Mare · 14 yrs

Casper, WY

Source: HorseWeb

Pony of the Americas (Pony of the Americas, Gelding) in West Townshend, VT

Pony of the Americas

Pony of the Americas · Gelding · 14 yrs

West Townshend, VT

Source: HorseWeb

Pony of the Americas (Pony of the Americas, Gelding) in Lancaster, PA

Pony of the Americas

Pony of the Americas · Gelding · 7 yrs

Lancaster, PA

Source: HorseWeb

Pony of the Americas (Pony of the Americas, Mare) in Central Point, OR

Pony of the Americas

Pony of the Americas · Mare · 13 yrs

Central Point, OR

Source: HorseWeb

Pony of the Americas (Pony of the Americas, Stallion) in Fort Scott, KS, KS

Pony of the Americas

Pony of the Americas · Stallion · 5 yrs

Fort Scott, KS, KS

Source: HorseWeb

Showing 97 to 107 of 107Save this search

Browse horses

Breed

Quarter Horse Paint Appaloosa Thoroughbred Arabian Morgan Tennessee Walking Horse Missouri Fox Trotter Standardbred Warmblood Friesian Andalusian / PRE Draft (Percheron, Belgian, Clydesdale, Shire)Pony (Welsh, POA, Shetland, Connemara)Miniature Horse Mustang American Saddlebred Rocky Mountain Horse Kentucky Mountain Saddle Horse Paso Fino Peruvian Horse Icelandic Horse Gypsy Vanner Lusitano Haflinger Norwegian Fjord Curly National Show Horse Irish Sport Horse Trakehner Selle Français Hanoverian Akhal-Teke American Cream Draft Clydesdale Percheron Belgian Draft Shire Suffolk Punch Welsh Pony and Cob Shetland Pony Connemara Pony of the Americas Hackney Oldenburg Holsteiner Dutch Warmblood Westphalian Lipizzan Spotted Saddle Horse Racking Horse Gaited grade horse Donkey Mule Grade / Unregistered Other

Breed guide

Pony of the Americas in the Animal Library

Price guide

Pony of the Americas horse prices