Pony of the Americas horses for sale priced Under $2,500
107 listings
107 Pony of the Americas horses for sale on other sites Everybarn indexes. Asking prices run from $300 to $2,500, with a median of $1,200 across 107 prices. Based on 107 listings, updated Oct 8, 2026. The most listings are in Deloit, IA (7), Columbia, MO (4) and Hillsdale, MI (4). Typical range nationally $850 to $3,000, from 151 comparable sales and listings in the past 90 days.
Everybarn Verified
Breed 1▼
Quarter Horse5471Paint2722Appaloosa746Thoroughbred1017Arabian1348Morgan190Tennessee Walking Horse23Missouri Fox Trotter177Standardbred107Warmblood173Friesian72Draft (Percheron, Belgian, Clydesdale, Shire)318Miniature Horse59Mustang226American Saddlebred4Rocky Mountain Horse4Kentucky Mountain Saddle Horse3Paso Fino154Peruvian Horse46Icelandic Horse1Gypsy Vanner9Lusitano6Haflinger109Norwegian Fjord1Curly30National Show Horse2Trakehner12Hanoverian11Shire11Welsh Pony and Cob184Shetland Pony112Connemara8✓Pony of the Americas107Hackney47Westphalian3Lipizzan8Spotted Saddle Horse19Racking Horse10Donkey111Mule217Show 107 horses
Distance ▼
Fair Value ▼
Showing 73 to 96 of 107Save this search