Connemara horses for sale priced Under $2,500

8 Connemara horses for sale on other sites Everybarn indexes. Asking prices run from $500 to $2,250, with a median of $1,000 across 8 prices. Based on 8 listings, updated Oct 8, 2026. The most listings are in Newton, WI (2). Typical range nationally $3,200 to $20,000, from 44 comparable sales and listings in the past 90 days.