Everybarn vs Craigslist

Updated October 4, 2026

Is Everybarn or Craigslist better for selling animals?

Craigslist does not allow pet sales, so for a sale Everybarn ($9.99 per listing, 0% commission) is the option of the two; Craigslist suits a free re-homing post.

Side by side

SiteSeller feesAnimals allowedBuyer safeguards
Everybarn$9.99 per listing for 90 days, 0% commission. Buyers pay nothing.Dogs, Cats, Horses, Reptiles & exotics, Birds, Livestock, AquaticsEvery seller passes an ID check before a listing goes live; papers the seller uploads are on file for the buyer to read.
CraigslistFree to post in most categories; paid categories are jobs, some housing and some vehicle and dealer postsPet sales are prohibited; re-homing with a small adoption fee is allowedNot published

"Not published" means we could not confirm the fact from the site's own public pages on the date checked. Check the site directly before you decide.

Where Craigslist may suit you better

  • Free to post a re-homing ad
  • Everybarn is newer, so a long-running site may have more buyers browsing today.

Where Everybarn may suit you better

  • A flat $9.99 per listing for 90 days and 0% commission, whatever the sale price.
  • Every seller passes an ID check before a listing goes live.
  • Papers you upload are on file for buyers to read.
  • Built only for animals, from dogs to cattle to koi.
Start a listing
How much does it cost to sell on Craigslist compared with Everybarn?

Craigslist: Free to post in most categories; paid categories are jobs, some housing and some vehicle and dealer posts. Everybarn: $9.99 per listing for 90 days and 0% commission.

What animals can you sell on Craigslist?

Pet sales are prohibited; re-homing with a small adoption fee is allowed.

Can I list on Craigslist and Everybarn at the same time?

Yes. A Everybarn listing does not stop you from selling anywhere else, as long as the other site's own rules allow it.

Sources