Sites like Keystone Puppies for selling animals

Updated October 4, 2026

What are the best sites like Keystone Puppies?

For the same animals, Hoobly, PuppyFinder, PetClassifieds.US and Everybarn are the closest options; the table shows what each charges sellers and allows.

The options

SiteSeller feesAnimals allowedBuyer safeguards
Everybarn$9.99 per listing for 90 days, 0% commission. Buyers pay nothing.Dogs, Cats, Horses, Reptiles & exotics, Birds, Livestock, AquaticsEvery seller passes an ID check before a listing goes live; papers the seller uploads are on file for the buyer to read.
HooblyFree basic ad ("Post Free Ad" on the home page)Many species, including dogs, birds and other petsNot published
PuppyFinderFree ads: 1 active ad without ID verification, up to 8 with it; paid breeder plans are also offeredDogs and puppiesOptional seller ID verification; ads from unverified sellers need administrator approval
PetClassifieds.USFree classifiedsDogs, cats, birds, fish, reptiles and farm animalsNot published
NextDayPetsFree ad ("Place a Free Ad")Dogs and puppiesNot published
Free Dog ListingsNot publishedDogs and puppiesNot published
Lancaster PuppiesNot publishedDogs and puppiesNot published
Greenfield PuppiesNot publishedDogs and puppiesA health guarantee page, and a filter for puppies with an extended health guarantee
Keystone PuppiesNot publishedDogs and puppiesA health guarantee on puppies and a delivery service, per its home page

"Not published" means we could not confirm the fact from the site's own public pages on the date checked. Check the site directly before you decide.

Start a listing
Is there a free alternative to Keystone Puppies?

Yes: Hoobly, PuppyFinder, PetClassifieds.US and NextDayPets publish a free option for sellers. Everybarn charges $9.99 per listing with 0% commission.

Sources